Contrary to Abigail Shrier’s “Irreversible Damage”, testosterone use in trans men is not associated with increased reproductive cancers

Zinnia JonesIrreversible Damage by Abigail Shrier has become one of the most celebrated books among anti-trans advocates for its popular and accessible repackaging of their movement’s current master narrative: that trans youth and young adults who come out are largely confused cis youth, mostly assigned female, adopting an inaccurate identity under the malign influence of social contacts, media, and culture. Its central arguments are founded on bad information. The supposedly “epidemic” growth in the population of trans youth constitutes an extremely small share of all youth, and may even represent underrecognition and undertreatment of trans youth. The proposed hypothesis for contagious spread of trans identity in youth, “rapid onset gender dysphoria”, is likely the result of an illusion created by the methodological choice to theorize based only on parents’ external perceptions of another’s onset of gender dysphoria; this shortcoming was later corrected by interviewing trans youth, with substantially different findings on this “rapidity”.

The main thrust of Irreversible Damage is to foment existing discomfort and panic among conservatives about “protecting” “their” “women and children” on the basis of this very thin evidence. Scientific misfires like “rapid onset gender dysphoria” are offered up as justification for political and personal sentiments that would persist anyway: the opposition to recognizing the authenticity and basic equality of trans people, and the belief that trans people are ambassadors of an unnatural and threatening social disease that must be met with hostile suppression. The pseudoscientific narrative dresses these positions in a pretense of respectability, as something a reasonable person could believe.

But there’s also a series of statements in Shrier’s book that have nothing to do with subtleties of statistics, demographics, or methodology. Instead, this appears to be a far more straightforward matter of factual findings. Shrier suggests repeatedly that trans men taking testosterone will experience an increased risk of endometrial, ovarian, or other reproductive cancer due to this transition treatment. However, existing literature on trans men using testosterone indicates that they do not face any higher risk of cancers at all. Continue reading

Posted in Breast, Endocrinology, Hoaxes, Oncology, Safety data, Transmasculine, Transphobia and prejudice | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Learning to love and accept your body: Testosterone helps adolescent trans boys do that

Zinnia JonesDiscussions of transgender issues among the general public often take an unproductive turn when the distress of gender dysphoria is cast as something that can be remedied by simply “accepting your body as it is”. Most forgivably, this may be just the initial impression of uninformed cis people who do not want us to continue to suffer that distress, and also incorrectly believe there may be an “easier” way to reach that point without the difficulties that can be associated with transitioning. Less understandable are those who do have the time to learn and clearly know better, but instead have chosen to spend their time arguing that transitioning is axiomatically undesirable, harmful, or immoral, and therefore no beneficial outcomes could possibly justify it anyway. Continue reading

Posted in Faith and religion, Gender dysphoria, Outcomes of transition, Philosophy and language, Transphobia and prejudice | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Trans Broken Brain Syndrome: When “subjective cognitive decline” becomes a subjective attack on trans healthcare

By Heather McNamara

Have you ever looked at an object and forgotten what it was called? Maybe you’ve been in the produce section of a grocery store, standing in front of the pineapples and found yourself thinking “Banana? Mango?” I have. In fact, as a stroke survivor and anxiety/depression sufferer, these moments occur more often than I’d like to admit. Sometimes, alternative suggestions don’t even come up. I can stare at an ordinary object for a full minute without a single clue as to what it’s called. I can say from experience that the seconds in that minute are very, very long as the situation gradually transforms from a humorous anecdote to an inconvenience to something I might Google later and finally something I know I need to talk to my doctor about. I often wonder: Do I not have the words at all? Will they come back? Will I be okay or will I eventually lose my ability to work and function in society altogether? Continue reading

Posted in COVID-19, Media, Personal, Transgender medicine | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Zinnia’s college adventures, year 3: A Florida public university is forcing us into conditions of unchecked pandemic exposure

Zinnia JonesI have been a student in the Florida community college and public university system since spring of 2019, and as of the fall 2021 semester it looks like just about everything that isn’t my own personal academic performance – including the educational system itself – has gone completely sideways. This is now the second summer where our state has been the global hotspot of the pandemic. During last year’s, I took summer semester off and spent a week in late June in an Orlando ICU with my wife as she was recovering from near-fatal strokes, then packed my fall schedule with whatever courses I could find that were available online. By this summer term, continuing to work toward my statistics degree required registering for classes that were only available in-person, and this has also been the case for this fall term. I am now attending fully in-person for the first time since spring 2019, this time at one of the largest universities in the country during a pandemic that is worse than ever and still worsening. Continue reading

Posted in COVID-19, Personal | Tagged | 1 Comment

Christian Institute: Stop calling our trans depersonalization resources a “transgender craze” of “rapid-onset gender dysphoria”

Zinnia JonesThe UK’s Christian Institute, in their September 2020 publication “The transgender craze” purporting to explain a “social contagion” of “rapid-onset gender dysphoria” in adolescents, takes a highly abbreviated excerpt from my own writing in 2013 on gender dysphoria and symptoms of depersonalization, a highly distressing dissociative syndrome that can occur more frequently among trans people and often remits following transition.

The Christian Institute asserts that these are “very commonly experienced adolescent anxieties” being incorrectly “used as ‘evidence’ that a young person is ‘truly transgender’”, and that “anxious people crying out for diagnosis and help from peers” are “the victims of this harmful advice”. The misattribution of my article to “Transgender Teen Survival Guide” appears to be copied from an error by Lisa Littman in her original 2018 publication on “Rapid-onset gender dysphoria in adolescents and young adults”, where a similar excerpt is described as “Vague and nonspecific symptoms called signs of GD”. Continue reading

Posted in Depersonalization, Faith and religion, Hoaxes, Media, Psychology and psychiatry, Transgender medicine, Transphobia and prejudice | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment